« 「東京大学の~」の続編でる。 | Main | 眠いぞ~ »

バークリーメソッドは理論ではない

「東京大学の~」を読んでいるのだが、まずは興味津々の最後のポストバークリーの所から読み始めた。
相変わらずLCCはオカルト扱い。 濱瀬元彦氏のラングメソッドのところでの、下方倍音がなにやらおもしろそうなのだが、さっと読んだだけでは何の事だかよく解らない。

他には、タイトルのようななかなかキャッチーなフレーズが飛び出してくる。でも、何でそうなのか?と言うのが、実はしっかり語られていない。この本、口述を文章化しているから、「なぜならば・・・」と言う視点とかが時折抜けているんだよね。

要は、あくまでメソッド(方法論)であって「<理論ではない>とみるべき」で、理論のようにそれですべてが解き明かされる、「唯一もの」なんかじゃない。 つまりは、物理の理論とかであればe=mc2みたいな方程式があって、その周辺に様々な論理や仮説が展開できるのだろうけれど、バークリーメソッドではそこまでの仮説→実証みたいな物が構築できているわけではなく、あくまでそこにある基本的な物の体制を整えて他の人が使いやすいようにしているにすぎない・・・。
ってことなんだろう。

でも、理論でもメソッドでもどっちでも良いから、かっちょええピアノが弾けるようになりたいもんだ・・・。

ということで、後ろから読んでいますが、相変わらずの複雑言語化やカタカナ化、サブカルチャー度は絶好調です。しかし、ホント物知りだよなぁ~、この人達・・・。

しかし、濱瀬氏の「ジャズイディオムの殆どがパーカーですからね・・・」という言葉が、僕的には妙に重かったりします。 やっぱり立ち戻るのはこれか!

|

« 「東京大学の~」の続編でる。 | Main | 眠いぞ~ »

「書籍・雑誌」カテゴリの記事

Comments

Art Moriです。
私も読みました。とにかく、ここまでジャズ史をサブカルチャー風の文章で、だけど難しいことを実は語っている。すごい本だと思いました。
しかし、この本を読んで、自分の音楽にヒントを得ようという人には期待はずれでしょうね。

Posted by: Art Mori | 2006.03.22 at 11:20 PM

どうも、おひさです。

でも、「人に頼っちゃいけない」「理論(メソッド)だけでも、作れない」「最新のジャズではバークリーメソッドは崩壊している」って事を知りつつ、「やっぱり、ジャズのイディオムの殆どはパーカー」をいう意見を聴くだけでも、ある意味では考え方のヒントにはなります。

でも、それって「この本読んでもできるようにはならないからね」と言っているのと同じ事っていうのが可笑しいですよね。

ヒントにならないと言えばならないし、すっごいなっていると言えばなっているという・・・・。

読んだ後ありがたがるにせよ、捨てるにせよ、一読する価値はあるユニークな本であること事は確かだと思う。

Posted by: おさっぷ | 2006.03.23 at 12:44 AM

こんにちは、なぜか 濱瀬+パーカーの 検索から来ました!

「ジャズイディオムの殆どがパーカーですからね・・・」の最初の実験台(アドリブをしない人間をできる人間に改造)が私なのですが、成果物としてはどないなものでしょう。
私はその学校でバッパー第一号として生成されたのですが、ハードバップより#twband の 方がうんと楽しいです。近親憎悪?
ちなみに立ち戻るのはオムニブックでなく原典、即ち自力での採譜と言われています。というわけで、ペン大向けこれを採譜中。http://mixi.jp/view_bbs.pl?id=51889757&comm_id=128182

今後ともよろしくお願いします。

Posted by: 金山 | 2011.02.05 at 11:05 AM

When some one searches for his essential thing, therefore he/she needs to be available that in detail, thus that thing is maintained over here.

Posted by: www.fedhav.Eu | 2014.03.11 at 08:02 AM

Hostgator can be a besst superb web hosting service to every one with thhe companies In 2011, Hostgator has begun its operations in India as Hostgator.in by staarting support office and data center in India.HostGator is usually an independent hosting company created by Brent Oxley. Today there're one of several world's 10 largest contains, but inspite of the growth, hhe still takes personal involvement in client satisfaction all of which will often handle concerns personally. an the Hostgator is the better hosting site to use

Posted by: wikis.ala.org | 2014.03.17 at 09:52 AM

Hello, I desire to subscribe for this weblog to get most up-to-date updates, thus where can i do it please help out.

Posted by: HostGator Black Friday Sale | 2014.11.24 at 03:47 PM

Hello, Neat post. There is an issue together with your web site in web explorer, would test this? IE still is the market chief and a big section of other folks will leave out your great writing due to this problem.

Posted by: Samual | 2015.03.01 at 02:52 AM

I read tɦis piece of writing fսlly about the comparison οf moѕt reсent and preceding technologies, іt's remarkable article.

Posted by: top 10 web hosting companies | 2015.03.26 at 09:12 PM

Informative article, totally ԝhаt I neеded.

Posted by: palacinke od heljde | 2015.03.26 at 09:16 PM

Wonderful beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a blog website? The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

Posted by: match.com free trial | 2015.04.06 at 12:27 PM

What's up, the whole thing is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing information, that's truly excellent, keep up writing.

Posted by: Hostgator Coupon | 2015.05.08 at 11:09 AM

As a general rule if you can see the battery in its holder without disturbing anything then you should be able to change it fairly easily.

Posted by: quizup xp booster hack | 2015.05.17 at 04:41 AM

After scanning this amazing website I recently could not keep without saying thanks from your underside of my heart!

Posted by: insurance billing | 2015.06.14 at 03:54 AM

Only important information is provided by this web site and I am subscribing to it this instant! Thank you guys!

Posted by: medisoft version 20 | 2015.06.17 at 07:27 PM

Quality articles is the key to invite the users to pay a visit the website, that's what this web site is providing.

Posted by: Tabatha | 2015.07.02 at 03:58 PM

I have been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or weblog posts in this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this site. Reading this information So i'm happy to show that I've a very good uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed. I most undoubtedly will make certain to do not put out of your mind this web site and give it a glance on a constant basis.

Posted by: Lyn | 2015.07.10 at 08:48 AM

Only valuable data is provided by this blog and I am checking to it this instant! Thankyou folks!

Posted by: as explained here | 2015.08.11 at 06:36 PM

I wanted to take the time to express my passion closer and this awesome blog! Loving it!

Posted by: running shoes for plantar fasciitis | 2015.08.16 at 07:45 AM

I am officially pleased with this website and that I desired to take some time to many thanks from my heart's bottom!

Posted by: YouTube | 2015.08.16 at 02:42 PM

Wow! I am actually clicked with by this website and that I could say nothing less than I enjoy it!

Posted by: click here | 2015.08.18 at 03:44 PM

I am basically satisfied with this particular website and that I wanted to take the time to thankyou in the underside of my heart!

Posted by: http://allyourcheats.com/ | 2015.08.31 at 02:31 AM

After looking over this wonderful website I just could not leave without saying thankyou from the base of my heart!

Posted by: Moviestar planet cheats android | 2015.08.31 at 07:30 PM

Whoa! This web site really ticks with me and that I can claim nothing less than I really like it!

Posted by: watch this video | 2015.09.02 at 02:46 PM

Wow! I am really clicked with by this blog and I can say nothing less than I love it!

Posted by: Renato | 2015.09.06 at 07:01 PM

I enjoy reading sites such as this! Causes me to feel an emotion that is cozy enjoyable and in addition enlightened! Thank you so much!

Posted by: Bongacams token hack | 2015.09.13 at 06:56 PM

This website offers just beneficial info and that I am checking to it this instant! Thank you folks!

Posted by: dentist be damned alice barnes | 2015.09.14 at 02:10 AM

Wow! I am actually clicked with by this blog and I can say nothing less than I enjoy it!

Posted by: GTA 5 cheats PC | 2015.09.14 at 02:55 PM

Stunning! That you don't come by information like this simply and that I am so grateful! Preserve it up people!

Posted by: water slide Tulsa | 2015.09.26 at 03:20 PM

My specialty is in Florida has Some factors in keeping using the north, but both have become different sites.

Posted by: oceanside california newspaper | 2016.05.28 at 12:01 AM

Oceanside hosts The Soccer Championships Beach Finals the pageant will be the biggest about the westcoast and takes place weekend after the evening in May of mommy.

Posted by: oceanside california beach | 2016.05.29 at 02:21 PM

DRAWBACKS: They'll not even look at you-but that's part of the Colorado snobbery and pretentious, shallow mentality.

Posted by: oceanside ca restaurants | 2016.06.11 at 02:52 AM

Chips Harbor Fish & in Oceanside, CA should match the statement - it's a lot closer to us southern Californians in Essex than Woodman's or the Clam Field in Ipswich!

Posted by: oceanside homes for sale | 2016.06.11 at 04:11 AM

For another pleasant and tranquil little key area Florida community, visit Gustine.

Posted by: oceanside plumbing and heating | 2016.06.11 at 04:41 AM

CA: On October 22, 2008 - All law-abiding dependable and inhabitants are prompted to be alert and cautious to the reputation on your own coastline of the Weatherly, quickly, and seriously arm'd Clipper LYNX.

Posted by: homes for sale oceanside california | 2016.06.11 at 11:13 AM

Furthermore, the Oceanside Airport provides as a flight-training ability for military pilots and our future flight, and of course a probable astronaut or two.

Posted by: oceanside restaurants | 2016.06.11 at 07:23 PM

Post a comment



(Not displayed with comment.)




TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://app.cocolog-nifty.com/t/trackback/3226/9208128

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference バークリーメソッドは理論ではない:

« 「東京大学の~」の続編でる。 | Main | 眠いぞ~ »